Refuses to Dismiss Case against Online Suicide Predator
A Minnesota judge has rejected a request to dismiss two felony charges
against suicide predator William Melchert-Dinkel on Tuesday, preparing
the way for the case to go to trial – a decision that a prominent
anti-euthanasia activist has welcomed as a sign that "sanity is
Melchert-Dinkel, 48, a former Minnesota nurse who admitted to
participating in online chats with 15 to 20 people about suicide, and
entering into fake suicide pacts with about 10 people, was charged in
April with two counts of aiding suicide in the 2005 hanging death of
Mark Drybrough, 32, of Conventry, England, and the 2008 drowning of
Carlton University student Nadia Kajouji, 18, of Brampton, Ontario.
Kajouji jumped into the freezing Rideau River in early March 2008. It
was later revealed that she had been in conversation in an internet
chat group with Melchert-Dinkel, who had been posing as a teenage girl.
The man had allegedly urged Kajouji to hang herself in front of a
webcam so others could watch and promised he would die with her.
In October, Melchert-Dinkel’s defense attorney, Terry Watkins, filed
written arguments with the court that sought to have the two charges
dropped on free speech grounds.
In the document, Watkins argued that the online communications
Melchert-Dinkel used when providing suicide advice was a form of
constitutionally protected speech, and that the Minnesota statute
criminalizing speech assisting suicide is unconstitutionally vague.
In his decision, Judge Neuville said that the protection of free speech
does not extend to online speech that encourages activities that are
defined as criminal offenses by state statute.
Minnesota State Statute states that, “Whoever intentionally advises,
encourages or assists another in taking the other’s own life may be
sentenced to imprisonment for not more than 15 years or to payment of a
fine of not more than $30,000, or both.”
“It is unquestioned that the state has a compelling interest to protect
and preserve life. Prohibiting persons from advising, encouraging, or
aiding others to take their own life furthers the State’s interest in
protecting and preserving life,” Judge Neuville wrote.
“[The statute] does not prevent people from expressing opinions or
discussing suicide. Rather, the statute only criminalizes a narrow and
precise type of speech, i.e., speech that intentionally and directly
advises, encourages, or aids a specific person to end their own life.
Thus, speech that directly encourages and imminently incites the act of
suicide ... falls outside the protection of the First Amendment.”
In response to Watkins' argument that the Minnesota statute
criminalizing speech assisting suicide is unconstitutionally vague,
Judge Neuville wrote that the statute “is definitive enough to allow an
ordinary person to know what conduct it prohibits ... and it is not
written in a way that encourages discriminatory enforcement. Therefore,
the Court finds that [the statute] is not unconstitutionally vague
according to the Constitutions of Minnesota and the United States.”
Alex Schadenberg, the chairman of the euthanasia prevention coalition,
said that, "William Melchert-Dinkel should be prosecuted and sentenced
as if he were sitting with Nadia Kajouji and encouraging or counseling
her to commit suicide,” and welcomed the judge’s ruling as a sign that
“sanity is prevailing.”
Schadenberg observed that Melchert-Dinkel "is not the only one who is
perpetrating these crimes for their own sick gains upon depressed and
vulnerable people," and said that the law must deal with internet
"Melchert-Dinkel committed a heinous crime when he took advantage of
Kajouji, a depressed first year student at Carlton University, and
convinced her that suicide was the best course of action.
"It is the same as pushing a person off a cliff," Schadenberg stated.
Melchert-Dinkel has entered a preliminary plea of not guilty and
requested a jury trial. The next court hearing is set for November 19.
Contact: Thaddeus M. Baklinski
Publish Date: November
here to return to
the Current Daily News
is the largest
grassroots pro-life organization in
Illinois. A non-profit organization, that serves as the state
coordinating body for local pro-life chapters representing thousands of
Illinois citizens working to restore respect for all human life in our
society. The IFRL is composed of people of different political
persuasions, various faiths and diverse economic, social and ethnic
backgrounds. Since 1973 the Illinois Federation for Right to Life has
been working to end abortion
and restore legal protection to those members of the
human family who are threatened by abortion, infanticide and euthanasia.
Diverse though we are, we hold one common belief - that
every human being has an inalienable right to life
that is precious and must be protected. IFRL is
dedicated to restoring the right to life to the unborn, and protection
for the disabled and the elderly. Click here to learn more about